Saturday, April 2, 2016

Reader Question Double Feature: Family Who Don't "Get it"

Today's post comes from two wonderful readers who are both dealing with family members who don't understand Goth. I'm hoping that this post will answer both of their questions and make sure that they can get more advice in the comments if needed. 



The first is from Azotsuru:

I'm 13, and I've recently been very interested in the Gothic subculture. I have a lot of questions on how to go about this without freaking out my parents(mostly my mom). But firstly, I'm African(and Christian), and my mom is kind of restricting.She doesn't wear make up, so i can't were it(even when I'm a lot older) and other things like that. I'm also worried that they may think I've turned into some Satan worshiper or something, I don't think they even know that goth is a thing. They may not understand,so I don't think I can tell them. What do I do?  -Anonymous

In my opinion, one of the best ways to be a Goth without making your parents freak out is not to play it up as a big deal. If you announce to your parents "I'm a Goth," they might immediately start to bring up those stereotypes that you mentioned. So, don't even bring up the word Goth. You can probably integrate wearing more black into your wardrobe, or listening to Goth music, or watching Gothy movies without causing a fuss. Some elements of Gothy style aren't even that outlandish, maybe a necklace shaped like an antique key or a black tiered skirt would work here. 

I know it is frustrating to have limits on how you dress, but remember that being unable to wear gothy makeup or super elaborate outfits doesn't make you less of a Goth. Many of us tone down our outfits for work or school or to be around family, you aren't alone in that. Just appreciating the subculture and enjoying the things other than clothing is perfectly fine. Who knows, maybe her mind will change as you get older, or when you leave home. 

I hope this helps!

The second letter is from ABG: 

My problems lie not with my parents. They in fact lie with my Grandmother on my Mothers' side. I have always been a Christian. My Grandmother apparently thinks that, because I'm a gothy type, that I am not Christian. (Stereotype much?) She constantly questions me on my religion every time she sees an opening. I continue to explain that 'Yes I'm still Christian' and 'No I'm not in an occult' and that 'Calm down. I'm an asthmatic remember? I don't smoke'. A typical opening would be 'So I saw this really adorable (fill in something totally innocent- such as a book -that is related to ghosts/various other things) and I like it.' 'Well Adilie, you know that ghosts aren't real right?' and she proceedes to talk to me about how 'God loves you so much.' Anywho- my question is: How do I explain goth to her? I've showed her videos by Jillian Venters (The Lady of Manners over at Gothic Charm School) that explain it, but she gets distracted by the fact the 'room looks weird' and basically brushes off everything that Jillian says.I remain, Mary Rose, your humble servant.ABG

In my opinion, dealing with grandparents and parents is much the same issue and, as above, it might be best not to add the name Goth (and all the stereotypes) to the mix. 

If you are yourself a Christian, it might be best to appeal to your grandmother using that. Something to the effect of "I am a Christian and do not think that being interested in Goth is a barrier between me and God. It's an interest that I have and I wish you would be supportive." If you go out of your way to demonstrate your faith to your grandmother (volunteer to go to church with her, ask her what her thoughts are on a particular bible story, etc.) she will be less likely to think that your other interests are at-odds with your Christianity.

You might also try to find some common ground with her about other things. Maybe she likes history, or other literature? Has she ever approved of something Gothy you've worn or liked (as small as a piece of jewelry, a particular outfit, something creative you've done)? Maybe bring that up. 

I don't know how your parents feel, but if your mother is supportive maybe you could ask her to talk to her mother. You could ask your mother "Hey mom, my grandmother is being very critical of my hobbies and I feel that it's really disruptive to our relationship. Could you tell her that I value our relationship and that I hope she knows I don't want my hobbies to get between us?"

I hope that helps!

Readers, how do you deal with family members who just don't "get it"?


8 comments:

  1. It's worth saying that, although it may not apply here, safety and your own wellbeing should come first when it comes to family who don't understand. If it's not safe for you to indulge fully in your interests or you feel that home life would be intolerable, it's maybe best to stealth goth until you can remove yourself from that situation. Obviously it sucks not being able to fully express yourself, but it might be wiser to wait until you have more independence. If you generally have a good relationship with your family this doesn't apply; as someone who never really bothered to announce gothic interests, it is a good method!

    For the second letter, I definitely recommend actively showing that you still have a strong connection to your faith. If your gran is still bringing it up without any resolution, Captain Awkward has really good advice on this - http://captainawkward.com/2015/04/13/688-parents-appearance-and-opinions/

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. What Fiona said. Not everyone's parents are understanding or kind or need to hear about your 'goth' 'lifestyle'. Some parents are monsters and those kids just need to endure until they're free. If being goth will ruin your relationship with them, get you thrown out on the street, subject you to harassment, best to go stealth until you move out.

      Delete
  2. This response is to the second letter. It just sounds like your grandmother just wants to get on your case and isn't really interested in what you have to say. Honestly, your faith is none of her business to question. Best have your mother talk to her about it.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Your blog has good looking. Nice picture. You have to include more information about this topic. Try to write all that information in your own words. You can use some imaginative writing tips in your blog to make more beautiful one. To get that information you can go through Best thesis writing service .

    ReplyDelete
  4. Luckily I am at an age where I don't need to look good for toxic people anymore. Sure, a bit of toning down for work but those who don't like me the way I am are welcome to leave :-) really liked your answer to the 1st question - makeup can be added at a later point and definitely better to start slow than to get your parents upset at the age of 13 :-)

    ReplyDelete
  5. I am very interested in the Gothic subculture. I had many doubts related to this. i want to write an article in case study report writing service. Your article helped me to understand more about Goth.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Couple of useful links to start with:
    http://www.independent.co.uk/arts-entertainment/music/features/dont-mock-goths-futures-bright-for-the-men-and-women-in-black-6106105.html

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sBu5BUkFMEk

    As far as Goth and church go they are not mutually exclusive. Unfortunately in German, http://www.ardmediathek.de/tv/Glaubw%C3%BCrdig/Glaubw%C3%BCrdig-Mareike-Greb/MDR-Fernsehen/Video?bcastId=7545428&documentId=28462098

    When it comes to it, anything "different" will be picked on by grandparents. Something to stress is that goth for a lot of people is simply a way of dressing, it's not a cult or anything that has fixed rules. As with any group of people, there are good and bad elements.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Conflicts of children and parents is the eternal theme. I think parents become accustomed to the the child's choice. I, too, have long been controversy about the subculture, but we have coped. Now, I often like to watch live busty cam and me no one forbids.

    ReplyDelete